PMI has a bad rep when it comes to getting a home loan. So, why might you actually want PMI?

There are volumes of over simplified, outdated and amateur financial advice on the internet today. Rumors about PMI may be one of the most common when it comes to mortgage loan advice. What’s the truth? How does it really work, and why is it actually something that some Seattle mortgage borrowers should ask for? 

What Is PMI?

PMI stands for Private Mortgage Insurance. 

When you put down less than a 20% down payment on a home, or you borrow more than 80% of the purchase price or value you’ll be required to get private mortgage insurance.

This is a third party insurance policy which is used when borrowers are taking out what appear to be ‘riskier’ home loans.

Borrowers typically pay this as a part of their monthly mortgage payment to the lender. It is based on a percentage of your total amount borrowed. 

Why Lenders Use PMI

Mortgage lenders ask for PMI to offset their risks in making larger loans, and when borrowers are putting down smaller down payments.

Lenders are the beneficiary of this insurance. If you default on your mortgage loan this helps compensate them or cover any losses.

It also gives them more confidence in making more aggressive loans. It allows them to share the risk, and still provide the programs people really need.

Why You Want PMI On Your Next Home Loan

No one wants to overpay for anything. We certainly don’t want to pay a penny more than we have to when it comes to our housing payments. We all like a good deal.

Yet, while we’ve been programmed to think PMI is bad, that isn’t necessarily the case. If you can avoid it by putting down tens of thousands of dollars extra when buying your next home in Seattle, and won’t miss the money, then it may be a smart move.

However, to just say “PMI is bad,” and not consider it, may be financially irresponsible.

Here are some of the reasons you might want it…

Save Huge By Getting The Home Now

Here’s the real trap people fall into by not considering PMI. It lets you buy a home sooner, with less money down.

Why does this matter so much? There are many benefits of homeownership. The sooner you can own instead of rent the better. At the most basic level it can help you save more on moving costs between apartments, and just throwing away money every month helping someone else own the property and building up their retirement nest egg. 

It can also help you save tens of thousands of dollars on buying the same home. Let’s say you find a home for $700,000. You can only afford a 5% down payment today. That means you might pay $130 a month in PMI. If you get a 30 year fixed rate loan at 2.75% interest your monthly P&I payment would be $2,714.80.

Now, if you didn’t want to pay PMI, you could wait until you can afford to make a 20% down payment. That’s an extra $105,000 down, based upon the same price. Of course, if that takes you another three years, and somehow that home you really loved comes back on the market, it is probably going to cost more. Over the very long term home prices go up on an average of 5% per year. Sometimes that is a lot more in Seattle. So, that same house would now probably cost at least $105,000 more. So, you’d actually need close to a $165,000 down payment to avoid PMI. 

In addition to having to put almost 5x as much money down, interest rates are on the rise. If interest rates increase to 5% in those years while you saved, your monthly P&I payment would actually be $3,457.13 per month. More than $700 extra per month. You’d pay an additional whopping $288,237.86 in interest alone over the life of your loan.

So, what’s better? $130 in PMI per month to get the home now, or over $300,000 more for the same home, if you can save that extra down payment in 3 years?

It's Temporary

Whereas your interest rate may be with you for 30 years, PMI is temporary. You only pay PMI until your loan balance falls beneath that 80% loan to value mark. Once you are in, then you may also have appreciation on your side. You may be able to request that it is removed from your loan in just three years. Or lenders will remove it voluntarily once you get down to around 78%. 

Borrow More And Stay Liquid

Even if you do have the money to make a 20% down payment today, it may be smarter to take a larger loan and keep more liquid cash on hand for emergencies. That gives you the most financial security and flexibility.

Alternatives To PMI

If you still don’t love the idea of that little PMI payment for now, then there are some alternatives.

This includes:


PMI has a bad reputation according to some online circles. Yet, when you really dig in and do the math for yourself, it can actually make the most sense. More than that, asking for a loan with PMI could save you hundreds of thousands of dollars on buying the same home now, rather than waiting, or stretching yourself to make a larger down payment. 

About the Author

Helping Seattleites buy their dream homes for over 15 years. Founder of Seattle's Mortgage Broker and author of Homeownership Simplified: The Truth about ZERO Down.